National Genealogical Society Quarterly Review, Winter 2026

National Genealogical Society Review 

Separating same-named individuals  living in the same location at the  same time is a common genealogical challenge. Sorting through widespread misinformation is a hurdle to overcome before a sound genealogical conclusion can be reached. To ascertain the truth, a researcher must know the subject matter thoroughly and conduct meticulousresearch to piece together evidence from reliable sources. Such is the case with three men named James Lea living in Caswell County , North Carolina, circa 1790: one on Country Line Creek; one onCobb's Creek; and one on Kilgore'sBranch. Past researchers have confused and conflated the trio. The Reverend Dr. Cynthia Forde-Beatty sets out to separate their identities with well-documented research to determinewhich one married the daughter of Lawrence Bankston in 1754. Forde-Beatty's passion for the subjectmatter is evident. At times she warns the reader to pay close attention to details not yet proven. To identify and separate the three Lea men she correlates evidence from tax lists, deeds, court records, and a diary. Forde-Beatty uses timelines, signature comparisons, and DNA evidence, and other tools to help the reader understand her research and finding.~.

Volume I provides detailed research conducted for each of the Lea men, discusses problem areas with past research-at times with an unnecessarily judgmental tone, and provides timelines and genealogies to illustrate findings. 

Volume 2 contains images and document transcriptions discussed throughout volume I. Although many also appear in volume I, this separate volume provides  a convenient reference while reading.

Volume 3 begins with a DNA overview and continues with a comprehensive DNA study for Lea and Lee test takers. Colored graphs illustrate   findings. The author also calls for future Lea test takers needed for a more comprehensive study. 

While portions of the genealogies in volume I are well cited with reliable sources, some statements lack proof. For example, some of the stated birth and death dates rely on undocumented Find a Grave memorials. Also, citing original records would be better than derivative and authored sources. At times, the volume lreads like a travelogue rather than a scholarly work, and could be further edited and condensed.

This work leaves room for improvement in meering genealogy standards.Nevertheless, Rev. Dr. Forde-Beatty has collected and correlated solid evidenc from reliable sources rhat separates the three James Leas in Caswell County, North Carolina, circa 1790.

Keith Beny, CG

Roanoke, Virginia

keirh@yourlineage.net

J'II Mrt!<e Me A lXlorld: lhe I 00-Year

Journey of Blrick Hist01y Month.

By Jarvis R. Givens. Published by

HarperCollins Publishers; 195

Broadway; New York, NY 10007;

www.harpercollins.com; 2026. ISBN

978-0-06-347882-4. 245